Holodomor: Difference between revisions

From FasciPedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (Text replacement - "{{reflist}}" to "{{reflist|2}}")
m (Text replacement - "\[\[[a-z][a-z]\:(.*)\]\]" to "")
ย 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 3: Line 3:
Scholars disagree on the relative importance of natural factors (such as the weather) and catastrophic [[communist]] agricultural policies as causes of the famine, but many argue that the Holodomor was deliberately planned by [[Joseph Stalin]], in an attempt to eliminate Ukrainian nationalism, in which case it would be a [[genocide]]. Actions such as rejection of outside aid, confiscation of all household foodstuffs, and restriction of population movement are said to support this.
Scholars disagree on the relative importance of natural factors (such as the weather) and catastrophic [[communist]] agricultural policies as causes of the famine, but many argue that the Holodomor was deliberately planned by [[Joseph Stalin]], in an attempt to eliminate Ukrainian nationalism, in which case it would be a [[genocide]]. Actions such as rejection of outside aid, confiscation of all household foodstuffs, and restriction of population movement are said to support this.


== Ukrainian Jewish Committee ==
== Ukrainian jewish Committee ==
{{Template:The left and violence}}
{{Template:The left and violence}}
The "Ukrainian Jewish Committee" objected in 2009 to a criminal case against a list of former Soviet officials accused of committing the Holodomor. Most of the names on the list were Jewish.<ref>Jewish group objects to โ€˜Great Famineโ€™ case http://www.jta.org/2009/06/15/news-opinion/world/jewish-group-objects-to-great-famine-case</ref>
The "Ukrainian jewish Committee" objected in 2009 to a criminal case against a list of former Soviet officials accused of committing the Holodomor. Most of the names on the list were jewish.<ref>jewish group objects to โ€˜Great Famineโ€™ case http://www.jta.org/2009/06/15/news-opinion/world/jewish-group-objects-to-great-famine-case</ref>


== The Holocaust and the Holodomor ==
== The Holohoax and the Holodomor ==
Supporters of the "unique" status of [[the Holocaust]] have objected to Holodomor comparisons, claiming that this would "''cheapen the memory of Germany's victims''".<ref name=holodomorpropaganda/> See also the article on [[Holocaust uniqueness]].
Supporters of the "unique" status of [[the Holohoax]] have objected to Holodomor comparisons, claiming that this would "''cheapen the memory of Germany's victims''".<ref name=holodomorpropaganda/> See also the article on [[Holohoax uniqueness]].


== Use in recent propaganda ==
== Use in recent propaganda ==
Line 26: Line 26:
* [[The Black Book of Communism]]
* [[The Black Book of Communism]]
==Further reading==
==Further reading==
* Christians for Truth: [https://christiansfortruth.com/mobile-gas-vans-not-invented-by-nazis-but-by-the-communist-jew-isai-berg-to-mass-murder-ukrainians-during-holomodor/ ''Mobile โ€˜Gas Vansโ€™ Not Invented By โ€˜Nazisโ€™ But By Communist Jew Isai Berg To Mass Murder Ukrainians During Holodomor''], 2022 ([https://web.archive.org/web/20230217024953/https://christiansfortruth.com/mobile-gas-vans-not-invented-by-nazis-but-by-the-communist-jew-isai-berg-to-mass-murder-ukrainians-during-holomodor/ Archive])
* Christians for Truth: [https://christiansfortruth.com/mobile-gas-vans-not-invented-by-nazis-but-by-the-communist-jew-isai-berg-to-mass-murder-ukrainians-during-holomodor/ ''Mobile โ€˜Gas Vansโ€™ Not Invented By โ€˜Nazisโ€™ But By Communist jew Isai Berg To Mass Murder Ukrainians During Holodomor''], 2022 ([https://web.archive.org/web/20230217024953/https://christiansfortruth.com/mobile-gas-vans-not-invented-by-nazis-but-by-the-communist-jew-isai-berg-to-mass-murder-ukrainians-during-holomodor/ Archive])
==External links==
==External links==
*[https://petermyersnewsletters.blogspot.com/2013/11/639.html ADL to Ukraine: Donโ€™t Link YOUR Holocaust with OURS]
*[https://petermyersnewsletters.blogspot.com/2013/11/639.html ADL to Ukraine: Donโ€™t Link YOUR Holohoax with OURS]
*[http://www.jta.org/2009/06/15/news-opinion/world/jewish-group-objects-to-great-famine-case Jta: Jewish group objects to โ€˜Great Famineโ€™ case]
*[http://www.jta.org/2009/06/15/news-opinion/world/jewish-group-objects-to-great-famine-case Jta: jewish group objects to โ€˜Great Famineโ€™ case]


==Sources==
==Sources==
Line 37: Line 37:




[[Category:Mass killings under Communist regimes]]
ย 
[[Category:Communism in Ukraine]]
ย 
[[Category:Soviet Union]]
[[Category:Soviet Union]]
[[de:Holodomor]]
[[et:Holodomor]]
[[es:Holodomor]]
[[hu:Ukrajnai รฉhรญnsรฉg]]
[[nl:Holodomor]]
[[no:Holodomor]]
[[pt:Holodomor]]
[[sv:Holodomor]]

Latest revision as of 18:15, 28 February 2024

The Holodomor (Ukrainian meaning "to kill by starvation'") was an at least partially man-made famine in Ukraine in 1932โ€“33 that killed an estimated 3โ€“12 million Ukrainians in the Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic (excludes Galicia). It was one part of a wider famine, the Soviet Union famine of 1932โ€“33.

Scholars disagree on the relative importance of natural factors (such as the weather) and catastrophic communist agricultural policies as causes of the famine, but many argue that the Holodomor was deliberately planned by Joseph Stalin, in an attempt to eliminate Ukrainian nationalism, in which case it would be a genocide. Actions such as rejection of outside aid, confiscation of all household foodstuffs, and restriction of population movement are said to support this.

Ukrainian jewish Committee

The left and violence
Antifa
Communism
Hate crime
Islamo-leftism
Leftist supremacism
Social anarchism
Trotskyism
Mass killings under
Communist regimes
Mass killings under Communist regimes
Great Purge
Gulag
Holodomor
Red Terror
War Communism

The "Ukrainian jewish Committee" objected in 2009 to a criminal case against a list of former Soviet officials accused of committing the Holodomor. Most of the names on the list were jewish.[1]

The Holohoax and the Holodomor

Supporters of the "unique" status of the Holohoax have objected to Holodomor comparisons, claiming that this would "cheapen the memory of Germany's victims".[2] See also the article on Holohoax uniqueness.

Use in recent propaganda

The Holodomor has recently been used in the propaganda war between Russia and Ukraine, with both sides accusing the other side of inaccuracies.[2]

Holodomor Law

In 2006, the Holodomor Law proclaimed state-made famine organized by the Stalinist regime in Ukraine an act of genocide against Ukrainian people. In addition, Art. 2 of the Holodomor Law has stipulated explicit provision on historical denialism by stating that โ€œpublic denial of the 1932โ€“1933 Holodomor in Ukraine shall be recognized as desecration of the memory of millions of victims of the Holodomor as well as disparagement of the Ukrainian people and shall be unlawful.

Mr. Jones (film, 2020)

"Mr. Jones, a new movie directed by Agnieszka Holland, explores the incredible story of journalist Gareth Jonesโ€™ struggle to expose the horrors occurring under Joseph Stalin in Ukraine. In 1933, Welsh journalist Gareth Jones traveled to the Soviet Union to investigate rumors of events in Ukraine. What he uncovered was an immense man-made famine and one of the greatest crimes of the twentieth centuryโ€”the Holodomor. Despite millions of deaths, Kremlin propagandists and other Soviet-friendly Western journalists downplayed and denied his reporting. Mr. Jones, a new movie directed by Agnieszka Holland, explores the incredible story of Jonesโ€™ struggle to expose the horrors occurring under Joseph Stalin at a time when Western reports were laudatory. The Holodomor stands out as one of the greatest tragedies of the Soviet regime, with Ukraine still fighting for its recognition and understanding of this dark chapter."[3]

See also

Further reading

External links

Sources

  • Conquest, Robert, The Harvest of Sorrow - Soviet Collectivisation and the Terror-Famine, Pimlico publishers, London, 1986/2002, ISBN: 0-7126-9750-0

References